Don’t Hire People Just Like Yourself: A Leadership Hiring Mistake
When I first became a manager with my own department, I had a clear vision for the kind of team I wanted to build.
Basically, I wanted people who thought like me.
Then my boss pulled me aside and explained why that was probably a mistake.
Watch the video below for the full story.
One of the Biggest Hiring Mistakes Leaders Make
When leaders first start building a team, it is easy to confuse familiar with effective. We naturally trust people who communicate the way we do, solve problems the way we do, and seem to see the world from the same angle.
That can make hiring feel easier, but it can also create a weaker team.
The point of a team is not to surround the leader with people who make them feel comfortable. The point is to bring together different strengths, backgrounds, instincts, and ways of thinking so the team can make better decisions and perform at a higher level.
Early in my leadership career, my boss gave me a piece of advice that stung a little at first, but turned out to be right. The team did not need another version of me. It needed people who could help in the places where I was not naturally strong.
That is a hard thing for a leader to hear, because most of us like to believe our strengths are the ones the team needs most. But if everyone brings the same strengths, the same blind spots usually come with them.
A team full of people who think the same way may feel aligned, but it can also become narrow. The same assumptions get repeated. The same questions go unasked. The same problems get missed because no one sees the gap.
This does not mean hiring people who are difficult for the sake of being different. It means paying attention to what the team is missing. Some people move quickly, while others see risk. Some are great at relationships, while others bring structure. Some push ideas forward, while others slow the room down long enough to notice what might go wrong.
That difference can be uncomfortable, especially for leaders who are used to being the strongest voice in the room. But if the goal is team performance, comfort is not the measure.
The better question is not, “Would I naturally work well with this person?”
The better question is, “What does this person bring that we do not already have?”
Why Hiring for Sameness Weakens Teams
Leaders often hire for comfort without realizing it. Familiarity can feel like good fit, but it may only mean someone thinks the same way you do.
Strong teams need complementary strengths. Good hiring is not about duplicating the leader. It is about building the range the team needs.
Different perspectives can improve performance. The right kind of difference helps teams challenge assumptions, see gaps, and make better decisions.
Hiring people who are different can feel uncomfortable. But leadership is not about building a team that feels most familiar. It is about building one that performs.
For access to all of my “Awkward Leader” videos, subscribe to my
